48 – Saudi Arabia’s love affair with barley – Part Two

06 August, 2020

by Sean Cowman – Markets Manager, AEGIC.

In Part One of this two-part series I explained some of the key factors underpinning Saudi Arabia’s long history of using barley for animal feed. Historically speaking, Australian barley has long dominated this market, however, due to a number of reasons the status-quo has recently been upended, effectively ending Australia’s dominance of the Saudi market for barley.

Black Sea and Baltic Sea barley now dominate the Saudi market.  This shift in trade-flows coincided with greater demand from China for Australian barley, which often at paid a premium for Australian FAQ barley resulting in greater volume directed to more lucrative markets in China.  A key point of appeal with the Chinese market is that it provides Australian barley with exposure to China’s huge beer/malt market, as well as its growing animal feed demand.  

The Chinese Fair Average Quality (FAQ) barley market offered Australian barley an attractive price premium relative to alternative animal feed markets.  The demand from China grew strongly in recent years, as shown in Figure 5 below, with a large swing in Australian barley exports from Saudi Arabia to China from 2014.  

Figure 5 – Australian barley exports by major destination – 2004-2018 (mt)

However, the past two years (2019 and 2020) has seen this growth in Chinese market grind to a halt, with China’s the anti-dumping claim against Australian and the continued impact of African Swine Fever (ASF) on China’s pig industry negatively impacting Australian barley exports.

China’s application of an 80% tariff on Australian barley imports from May 2020, for a period of five years, will see Australian barley exports redirected towards other markets, including Saudi Arabia. However, despite Saudi Arabia remaining the largest importer of feed barley globally, the political and economic landscape within the Kingdom is moving towards reducing it barley imports and moving more to compound feeds.

The Kingdom’s push towards growing production of processed feed

The Saudi government has been encouraging a shift from raw, unprocessed barley to processed feed instead, with an ambitious goal of reducing barley imports by around 2 million tonnes, from 8mmt to 6mmt by 2021.

The USDA reported in 2018/19 barley actual usage was 6.3mmt (initially forecast to be 7.0mmt). In 2019/20 barley usage is estimated to increase 6.7mmt due to poor pasture condition year on year.

Figure 6 – Saudi Arabia’s barley consumption from 2004-2020 (Source: USDA)

For the past several years, the Saudi government has subsidised a range of imported feed grains and feed ingredients, including –

  • yellow corn
  • soybean meal (SBM)
  • dried distillers grains with soluble (DDGS)
  • corn-gluten feed (CGF)
  • sorghum
  • barley straw
  • sunflower meal
  • sugar cane molasses
  • alfalfa hay
  • rice hulls. 

The purpose of this support was to help grow the volume of locally-produced, processed feed and support domestic livestock producers by giving them greater access to nutritionally dense feed sources at competitive prices.  

The subsidy rates are calculated according to energy and protein contents of each feed ingredient. Compound feed is priced to the market at similar levels to government subsidised feed barley (USD9.60 for 50kg bag).   Despite the obvious commercial and nutritional density benefits of compound feed being available to buy for the price normally paid for unprocessed barley, Bedouin herders – the largest buyers of the feed barley in Saudi Arabia – remain unconvinced and continue to prefer unprocessed barley. This is despite the government’s ongoing education and awareness campaign aimed at selling the idea of using compound feed.  For example, the Ministry Of Agriculture (MOA) provided research findings showing that more than 20 percent of raw barley fed to livestock passes undigested through the animal’s GI tract before being rectally ejected. Despite such government advocacy for compound feed, so far at least, Bedouin herders remain wedded to their historical preference for unprocessed feed barley.  Among other considerations is familiarity and use in feeding barley compared to processed feed. 

The Arabian Agricultural Services Company (ARASCO) is the largest Saudi animal feed processor, with compound feed production capacity of 4mmt.  A key component of ARASCO’s marketing is its messaging that compound feed is a more efficient source of nutrients and, appealing to national interests, a more water efficient option for the Kingdom.   In recent years, ARASCO has maintained the price of compound feed at a similar level to the government’s sales price for unprocessed barley of the same weight.

In 2018, the Saudi government provided around USD$1.5 billion in feed subsidies – of which around USD$1 billion (two-thirds) was spent on barley alone (source: USDA). The remaining balance was split across another 23 grains and feed ingredients, including hay, corn and soybean meal. 

In early 2020, the Saudi government made revisions to their animal feed subsidy program. Namely –

  • As of the 1st of January, 2020, the animal feed subsidy for 23 imported feed grains and ingredients was ceased
  • From the 12th of January 2020, domestic feed barley sales prices were increased by 11%. This equated to an increase of around USD$1.07, from around USD$9.60 to USD$10.67 per 50kg bag. 
  • A new feed subsidy payment was introduced for small livestock famers with less than 300 animals. The subsidy is calculated per head and paid monthly.
  • The poultry industry to directly receive new, annual, production-based subsides
  • Increased subsidies on a range of forage and forage products.
  • In comparison, the same quantity of processed feed sells for only USD$0.05 more than raw barley.  

 The total level of funding allocated to these support measures, across four livestock categories (sheep, goat, camel, and cattle) is reported  to be around USD$320m per annum (source: USDA). The new barley pricing policy allows for prices to be adjusted to reflect prevailing international prices. 

Any move from unprocessed, direct-fed grains to processed, compound feed benefits those nations who product and export corn, soybeans or soybean meal eg USA.  These energy-dense feeds are heavily favoured by compounders looking to produce rations with the least cost per kilojoule.

Forage

As part of its water conservation imperative, in 2016 the Saudi government decided to halt almost all production of hay by 2019. For reference, in 2016, Saudi Arabia hay production was 4mmt in 2017 (total forage production was over 10mmt). The new government policy increases import subsidies on a range of forage products by up to 134% to stimulate and support imports.    Saudi Arabia imported 685,000mt of hay in 2016 and over a 1 mmt in 2017 (up from zero five years earlier).  It is estimated the imports of forage hays could increase to 3mmt.  In Saudi Arabia, hay (mostly alfalfa hay)  is predominantly used in dairy production, however, some forage is also used by feed millers and the traditional livestock sector.

Saudi market for Australian barley exports in the medium to longer term

For the foreseeable future, Saudi barley import volumes will be at the mercy of government policies and, in particular, subsidies for barley, relative to other grains and locally produced compound feed. The government will have the daunting task of navigating a workable pathway through a number of competing interests. In the context of barley imports, chief among these challenges will be striking the right balance between the Kingdom’s need to conserve dwindling water supplies, the needs of the vocal Bedouin herders and the financial impact of support for the various local sectors that either produce or consume animal feed.

More News

05 May, 2021

The world of noodles

Australian wheat is highly valued for noodles across Asia. The Asian noodle market represents over one-third of Australia’s wheat exports! Why Australian wheat? Flour millers across Asia prefer to buy Australian wheat for noodles. The combination of excellent noodle texture and colour attributes is unique to Australian wheat. White Australian wheat results in high milling yield […]

28 April, 2021

AEGIC IS HIRING

This post is current as of April/May 2021.  AEGIC is Australia’s leading organisation for market insight, innovation and applied solutions for the grains industry. We leverage our technical know-how, market insight and innovation capabilities to find and deliver practical solutions that create value for the Australian grains industry. We are currently building our technical capacity […]

27 April, 2021

AEGIC behind the scenes: Australian wheat for Asian bread

Asian diets are changing amid strong economic growth and increasing wealth. More and more consumers are recognising the benefits and convenience of baked products. Australia is well-placed to play a positive role in this change by understanding industry requirements. AEGIC’s bread research lab helps assess Australian wheat for Asian baking to get more of it into […]

21 April, 2021

AEGIC behind the scenes: Australian wheat for Asian noodles

The Japanese udon noodle market is Australia’s most stable premium wheat market. Japanese noodle lovers know what they like when they’re tucking into a delicious bowl of udon or ramen noodles. AEGIC runs a highly-trained udon noodle sensory evaluation program with the Japanese Flour Millers Association (JFMA) to ensure new Australian wheat varieties meet Japan’s strict requirements. […]

15 April, 2021

Enhancing noodle texture and colour

Asian flour millers prefer to buy Australian wheat for noodles because of its bright, stable colour and good texture. Thanks to a landmark AEGIC research project*, we know that noodle colour, colour stability, and texture are among the most important factors that flour millers look for when buying wheat for noodles. The research found that […]

13 April, 2021

50 – The Rise of the Middle Class

02 March, 2021

Whole grain for better health

Increasing whole grain consumption represents a major opportunity and challenge for the food industry. Extensive evidence now shows the connection between whole grain consumption and reduced risk of several chronic diet-related diseases. Greater intake of whole grains in the diet leads to reduced incidence of cardiovascular diseases, gastrointestinal diseases, cancer, and diabetes. To address this […]

26 February, 2021

AGIC Asia 2021 to reach Asian feed and whole grain buyers

The Australian Grain Industry Conference 2021 will feature a special session led by AEGIC on the benefits of Australian grains for animal feed, and the health benefits of whole grains for human consumption. AGIC Asia, which will be held virtually this year on Wednesday 3 March 2021, is a key date on the grain industry […]

05 February, 2021

Stimulating Australian feed grain demand in the Philippines and Thailand

Feed grain buyers in the Philippines and Thailand learned the compelling benefits of using Australian feed grains for swine following two well-attended AEGIC webinars this week. The webinars, presented in conjunction with Austrade, featured experienced Australian feed nutrition expert Tony Edwards as keynote speaker. The Philippines event attracted 150 representatives of the grain and animal […]

Slider